Mutual Fund Scheme Selection

1Start from the investor, not the scheme

The selection process runs in this order: goals → risk profile → asset allocation → category → scheme → option. The investor's time horizon matters more than age: two investors of the same age can have very different goals, horizons and finances.

Example A 35-year-old with a stable job, saving for retirement in 25 years, can take equity risk: diversified equity funds such as flexi cap or large & mid cap suit him. If the same person needs the money in 8 months, equity is unsuitable, because it can be very volatile over short periods.

Exam trap Equity is unsuitable for short horizons because of short-term volatility, not because equity funds cannot be redeemed within a year.

Remember

• Goals → risk profile → asset allocation → category → scheme → option.
• Horizon matters more than age.

Practise this concept (6 questions)

2Risk levels across scheme types

In increasing order of risk and potential return: liquid funds → debt funds → hybrid funds → equity funds.

Within debt, interest rate risk rises with duration: overnight → liquid → ultra short → short → medium → long duration. Credit risk rises from gilt → banking & PSU → corporate bond → credit risk funds. Within equity, risk generally rises from large cap → large & mid cap → mid cap → small cap, and from diversified → focused → thematic → sector funds.

Different schemes can face different kinds of risk, so they cannot always be ranked on one scale.

Example A large-cap-only banking sector fund is concentrated in one industry; a diversified small-cap fund is exposed to smaller, more volatile companies. Their risks are different in kind, not simply higher or lower.

Remember

• Liquid → debt → hybrid → equity.
• Concentration risk and company-size risk are different risks.

Practise this concept (8 questions)

3Matching strategy and style to the investor

• Core and satellite: the core is long-term, diversified holdings (large cap, flexi cap, index funds). The satellite is a smaller, tactical part, such as a sector fund bought because the sector cycle looks favourable, which needs skill and close monitoring.
• Mid and small caps: smaller companies are more vulnerable in downturns and need careful selection, so a large allocation adds volatility.
• Growth vs value: growth funds tend to outperform in bull markets; value funds tend to do better in falling markets or over long periods.
• Open-ended vs close-ended: open-ended funds keep some cash for redemptions and face pressure from large flows; close-ended funds can stay fully invested, but you can exit early only by selling on the exchange.
• FMPs and Target Maturity Funds: for predictable debt returns over a fixed horizon. An FMP can be exited before maturity only by selling on the stock exchange. An index-based TMF maturing around the investor's horizon is open-ended.
• Hybrids: "conservative" in a conservative hybrid fund refers only to its low equity share (10–25%), not to the riskiness of the bonds or shares it holds. Building your own mix of separate equity and debt funds gives more control; a hybrid fund simplifies decisions but fixes the mix.
• Gold: a Gold ETF tracks the price of gold; a gold sector fund holds shares of mining companies, which depend on company profits as well.
• Style drift: a "value fund" full of expensive momentum stocks may not be true to its promised style. An ultra short duration fund holding many low-rated papers carries more credit risk than its name suggests.

Example A moderate investor keeps 80% in a flexi cap fund and an index fund (core) and 20% in a banking sector fund (satellite) because he expects the banking cycle to improve.

Remember

• Core = diversified and long-term; satellite = tactical and smaller.
• Check that a fund is true to its stated style.

Practise this concept (17 questions)

4Comparing schemes and fund houses

Look for funds that consistently beat their benchmark and peers over long periods (at least 5 years for equity) and protect the downside in falling markets, rather than the one with the best return last quarter.

• Fund size: a very large AUM helps large-cap funds but can hurt mid-cap or sector funds that have a limited universe of stocks to buy.
• Track record: especially important for categories with a wide universe, such as multi cap funds.
• Portfolio turnover = lower of purchases or sales ÷ average net assets. 300% turnover means the average holding is only about 4 months, too short for a value style, and it adds trading costs.
• Star ratings mostly reflect past performance and have no predictive power; understand the method behind them.
• Switching every quarter to the top-ranked fund is a poor strategy: leaders change often, and exit loads and taxes eat into returns.

Example A fund bought ₹4,000 crore and sold ₹5,000 crore of shares in a year, with average net assets of ₹8,000 crore. Turnover = 4,000 ÷ 8,000 = 50%, so the average holding period is about 2 years.

Remember

• Consistency and downside protection beat last quarter's ranking.
• High turnover = short holding periods and higher costs.

Practise this concept (11 questions)

5Choosing the option

For a regular income, growth option + SWP is usually better than the IDCW option: IDCW is taxed at the slab rate and can be paid only from distributable surplus, so a "monthly IDCW" option does not guarantee monthly income. IDCW may suit investors whose income is tax-exempt.

Example A retiree wants ₹20,000 a month. With an SWP from the growth option, she withdraws exactly that amount each month, and only the gain portion of each withdrawal is taxed as capital gains. Monthly IDCW might be skipped if the scheme has no surplus.

Remember

• Growth + SWP is usually better than IDCW for regular income.
• IDCW needs distributable surplus.

Practise this concept (3 questions)

6Do's and don'ts for distributors

Do:

• Make sure every scheme is suitable for the investor.
• Stick to the investor's agreed asset allocation.
• Understand each scheme's objective and strategy.
• Check exit loads and taxes before suggesting a redemption.
• Follow a written, consistent scheme-selection method, so every client is treated by the same standards.
• Show your registered name and ARN on social media handles and marketing content.

Don't:

• Recommend a scheme mainly because it topped recent return charts.
• Chase past performance or switch clients frequently.

Example A client needs ₹2 lakh. He holds an equity fund bought 10 months ago (1% exit load within a year, and short-term capital gains tax) and a liquid fund. Redeeming the liquid fund is usually cheaper, after comparing exit load and tax.

Remember

• Suitability first; consistent written method; check loads and tax.

Practise this concept (5 questions)